Post by choco on Sept 3, 2020 23:17:43 GMT -5
Hi there. I didn't know the game started already, sorry. Am here now, looking at the discard now.
Also, I know this game is a different from the usual 'choose 1 out of 2 roles' approach when it comes to deciding them but rather combining an alignment and ability from the 2 out of 3 card and the last one gets automatically discarded but I'm just analysing what's thrown away for the time being.
1. Sophia - Mafia Strongman (A very powerful mafia role, but with infinite shots so ultra Powerful with a capitalised P, I don't know if Sophia would have chosen another scum role over this consider that this is a pretty nice one, unless she's got another nice town role; but if I have recalled correctly, Sophia doesn't like playing as scum as much as town so she's prolly good this time. Prolly not anti-town.)
2. Bella - Town Mason (Not much to look into with this discard, Mason is not indicative of any alignment/role in my opinion. It's basic and not exciting in a game of Greatest Idea so she could have chosen anything with better PR than this, could be anything that is not scum.)
3. Zinnia - Ascetic Townie (Yeah, this one is pretty boring, too, in my opinion. But it's always difficult for me to predict what alignment Zinnia would select to join by discarding townie. She doesn't object to the idea of playing as any alignment in this game except for goos, I think.)
4. Skelda - Hirsute Mafia Goon (An MG that investigates as werewolf? What kind of poopy role is this? Would literally pick anything to get rid of this, so not surprised that this is on the list.)
5. Rosey - Mafia Tracker (Not as useful in a setup where all is moving around using their special abilities during their night when almost every one is guaranteed a PR. Could have picked a more useful PR as mafia or as another alignment.)
6. Katie - Town Vigilante (Not a lot of people like playing as a vigilante, maybe her other combinations are a lot more exciting than this? I haven't played with Katie recently to think what she would prefer.)
7. Leilah - Vanilla Townie (Can understand why this is discarded, but other than that, I don't think I've played with Leilah before so I don't know which alignment they are more prone to playing as)
8. Frenchy - Town Mason Lover (LOL, what's with you and Bella, lovers think alike it seems. But yeah, this role isn't that great either. Not indicative of alignment either.)
9. Lala - Town Compulsive Childkiller (I would have picked anything that isn't a childkiller, too.)
10. Song - Mafia Lover (So many lover this time, could have been a ride, lol. Like Leilah, I don't know much about Song either.)
11. City - Vanilla Townie (I hope you didn't get a scum role this time, City. I hope you are finally off the streak)
12. Choco - Cult One-shot Goomaker (You kidding me, two of my least favourite things combined as an offering. It goes straight to the bin.)
TL;DR A lot of them are just 'I don't know, could be bad, but could also be good, this role is bad.' but it's what I think of those roles at first sight. For my own reference.
Also, I know this game is a different from the usual 'choose 1 out of 2 roles' approach when it comes to deciding them but rather combining an alignment and ability from the 2 out of 3 card and the last one gets automatically discarded but I'm just analysing what's thrown away for the time being.
1. Sophia - Mafia Strongman (A very powerful mafia role, but with infinite shots so ultra Powerful with a capitalised P, I don't know if Sophia would have chosen another scum role over this consider that this is a pretty nice one, unless she's got another nice town role; but if I have recalled correctly, Sophia doesn't like playing as scum as much as town so she's prolly good this time. Prolly not anti-town.)
2. Bella - Town Mason (Not much to look into with this discard, Mason is not indicative of any alignment/role in my opinion. It's basic and not exciting in a game of Greatest Idea so she could have chosen anything with better PR than this, could be anything that is not scum.)
3. Zinnia - Ascetic Townie (Yeah, this one is pretty boring, too, in my opinion. But it's always difficult for me to predict what alignment Zinnia would select to join by discarding townie. She doesn't object to the idea of playing as any alignment in this game except for goos, I think.)
4. Skelda - Hirsute Mafia Goon (An MG that investigates as werewolf? What kind of poopy role is this? Would literally pick anything to get rid of this, so not surprised that this is on the list.)
5. Rosey - Mafia Tracker (Not as useful in a setup where all is moving around using their special abilities during their night when almost every one is guaranteed a PR. Could have picked a more useful PR as mafia or as another alignment.)
6. Katie - Town Vigilante (Not a lot of people like playing as a vigilante, maybe her other combinations are a lot more exciting than this? I haven't played with Katie recently to think what she would prefer.)
7. Leilah - Vanilla Townie (Can understand why this is discarded, but other than that, I don't think I've played with Leilah before so I don't know which alignment they are more prone to playing as)
8. Frenchy - Town Mason Lover (LOL, what's with you and Bella, lovers think alike it seems. But yeah, this role isn't that great either. Not indicative of alignment either.)
9. Lala - Town Compulsive Childkiller (I would have picked anything that isn't a childkiller, too.)
10. Song - Mafia Lover (So many lover this time, could have been a ride, lol. Like Leilah, I don't know much about Song either.)
11. City - Vanilla Townie (I hope you didn't get a scum role this time, City. I hope you are finally off the streak)
12. Choco - Cult One-shot Goomaker (You kidding me, two of my least favourite things combined as an offering. It goes straight to the bin.)
TL;DR A lot of them are just 'I don't know, could be bad, but could also be good, this role is bad.' but it's what I think of those roles at first sight. For my own reference.