Post by sophia on Jun 20, 2020 5:57:46 GMT -5
After an hour of writer’s block (yes, I also cannot believe I got writer’s block for a freaking readslist for a mafia game 
) and general demotivation from the auto-refreshing disaster that wiped my readslist twice, I finally finished it. Now my fingers are aching from typing so much. Please know that almost all of my reads as of yet are subject to change and it’s not my final opinion on anyone. It’s just day 2.
~Keyen: Was fairly inactive on day 1, but he said he forgot about the game. Today he’s been really active so far. He doesn’t seem to be acting like how he did in Mouse’s mafia game where he was scum, and seems to be acting more like how he normally plays when he’s town. I haven’t seen any posts from him that seems scummy. At the moment, he is my most townread. - Probably Town 70/30
~City: Hasn’t talked yet for me to form a concrete opinion. Their overwhelming inactivity means I have no clue on what to think. Need more posts from them. - Unsure 50/50
~Luna: Doesn’t seem to be acting the same way she did last game where she was scum & more accusatory. I feel like I can read Luna like a book when she’s scum XD But in all seriousness, she’s been fairly active so far and hasn’t done or said anything that seems scummy to me. She actually tried scumhunting as well which is unlike her, but it’s more like the townish kind of scumhunting rather than the scummy pointing-fingers kind of scumhunting. She has a particular playstyle when she’s town, and she seems to be following that playstyle. For now, I’ll go with - Leaning Town 65/35
~Scherzo: Would you look at that? Yet ANOTHER inactive person! So far, since the game started, they’ve only posted two times. Two!! 😐 Anyway, their last post was a list that, to me, seems really rushed & incomplete. See for yourself:
1. Sophia i don't know
2. Keyen he hasn't talked in awhile
3. City i don't know
4. Luna well queen so good
5. Bella town i think
6. Skelda i think skelda is good
7: Scherzo great
8: Rosey i don't know
9: Lala i don't trust lala
10: Frenchy townish
11: Ham town
12: Broncos town i think
13: Choco i don't know
What I think is worth noting is that they put town for Bella, who turned out to be mafia, but put “i don’t know” for people who I think seem town like Lala. I also don’t understand why he put townish for Frenchy instead of someone else like Lala, who I think has done more to deserve a townread. But I can’t really come to a conclusion from just 2 posts, so I’m going to have to wait until they hopefully start talking more to form a concrete opinion. For now, I’m going with - Unsure, maybe scum? 49/51
~Rosey: Was fairly active on day 1. Most of their posts were playful and messing around, but they did some light contributing/scumhunting here and there too but not as much as I would like them to. They said that they didn’t like everyone piling on Bella like that, and wanted to start a “counter wagon” with Broncos, which I think is something worth noting considering Bella turned out to be mafia. This leads me to think they might be buddies (Bella & Rosey, not Rosey & Broncos although that may be possible too). However, I don’t exactly know how they usually play, because this is my first game with them so I’m unsure on what to think. They haven’t really done anything scummy other than that and most of their other posts seems townish to me. This is subject to change as Rosey posts more, but for now I’m going with - Unsure, Maybe Town? 54.578/45.422 (54 was not enough but 55 was too much
)
~Lala: Has been one of the most active players on both days 1 and 2. Has scumhunted and contributed the most as well, which makes me give her lots of towncred. Lala is kind of hard to read in general, and it doesn’t make it any better that the only game I’ve played where she was scum, she acted basically identical to how she usually plays as town. But she hasn’t done or said anything that strikes me as scummy, and that combined with the towncred & her activity makes me go with - Leaning Town 70/30
~Frenchy: Was not that active on day 1 and hasn’t talked yet today. Has not scumhunted nor contributed either. I really did not like their wacky self vote & their reasoning for changing their vote to Ham, which you can see for yourself here:
Interesting that hamtree is the person Lala asked about. Not sure what I make of that.I voted for them because you people were saying it was a crazy coincidence that both of us said what we said, so one of us might be scum, and since I know I'm townie, I thought maybe they were the one.
Something that I think is worth noting is that Ham actually posted their post BEFORE Frenchy posted, so their reasoning about it being a crazy coincidence that both of them said what they said and that one of them might be scum is pretty odd. I want to hear more from them because they are one of the only players who haven’t contributed yet. But something about them irks me and the reasoning post seems like a rushed coverup as to why they voted for someone to try and save their potential partner (Bella). This is subject to change as Frenchy starts posting more and if they defend themselves, but for now I’m going with - Leaning Scum 45/55
~Broncos: Was fairly active on day 1 and hasn’t been online as of yet today. From what I can remember, I think they were lightly scumhunting & contributing here and there. After Bella turned out to be scum and I was reading through the posts, their vote on Frenchy while there were many votes on Bella seemed odd to me. It felt like they were trying to start a counter-wagon on a new player who isn’t able to defend themselves properly to try and get the townies to come over so they can save their buddy. Broncos is just hard to read in general and it doesn’t make it better that I’ve only played a few games with them and I don’t know their playstyle. Again, this is subject to change as they start posting more & defending themselves, but for now I’m going with - Leaning Scum? 45/55
~Choco: Has been pretty active on both days 1 and 2, and has contributed a lot, which makes me give them some towncred. I didn’t like how they started thinking I’m scum seemingly just because I questioned them yesterday, and it made me rethink my read on him. Although their explanations as to why they said the things they said seems genuine & townish to me, and I’m inclined to trust them because they’re one of those people who always seem town (e.g Keyen, Dekay). The list that they made:
Playerlist:
1. Sophia - Neutral ground, leaning scum, the way she plays this game reminds me of her Arianna alter-ego in Keyen's anon game but could theoretically speaking, playing as town trying to make an effort in scumhunting, in which case makes her appear townish in my book at the same time. I'm actually unsure about her.
-seemed well made, but the fact that there were so many neutrals when at this point people would probably have a clear read on atleast some people sticked out to me as weird. I don’t know what to think of him, so I’m probably going to wait atleast a couple more days to reach a conclusion. AGAIN, this is most definitely subject to change, so for now I’m going with - Leaning Town? 55/45
) and general demotivation from the auto-refreshing disaster that wiped my readslist twice, I finally finished it. Now my fingers are aching from typing so much. Please know that almost all of my reads as of yet are subject to change and it’s not my final opinion on anyone. It’s just day 2.~Keyen: Was fairly inactive on day 1, but he said he forgot about the game. Today he’s been really active so far. He doesn’t seem to be acting like how he did in Mouse’s mafia game where he was scum, and seems to be acting more like how he normally plays when he’s town. I haven’t seen any posts from him that seems scummy. At the moment, he is my most townread. - Probably Town 70/30
~City: Hasn’t talked yet for me to form a concrete opinion. Their overwhelming inactivity means I have no clue on what to think. Need more posts from them. - Unsure 50/50
~Luna: Doesn’t seem to be acting the same way she did last game where she was scum & more accusatory. I feel like I can read Luna like a book when she’s scum XD But in all seriousness, she’s been fairly active so far and hasn’t done or said anything that seems scummy to me. She actually tried scumhunting as well which is unlike her, but it’s more like the townish kind of scumhunting rather than the scummy pointing-fingers kind of scumhunting. She has a particular playstyle when she’s town, and she seems to be following that playstyle. For now, I’ll go with - Leaning Town 65/35
~Scherzo: Would you look at that? Yet ANOTHER inactive person! So far, since the game started, they’ve only posted two times. Two!! 😐 Anyway, their last post was a list that, to me, seems really rushed & incomplete. See for yourself:
2. Keyen he hasn't talked in awhile
3. City i don't know
4. Luna well queen so good
5. Bella town i think
6. Skelda i think skelda is good
7: Scherzo great
8: Rosey i don't know
9: Lala i don't trust lala
10: Frenchy townish
11: Ham town
12: Broncos town i think
13: Choco i don't know
What I think is worth noting is that they put town for Bella, who turned out to be mafia, but put “i don’t know” for people who I think seem town like Lala. I also don’t understand why he put townish for Frenchy instead of someone else like Lala, who I think has done more to deserve a townread. But I can’t really come to a conclusion from just 2 posts, so I’m going to have to wait until they hopefully start talking more to form a concrete opinion. For now, I’m going with - Unsure, maybe scum? 49/51
~Rosey: Was fairly active on day 1. Most of their posts were playful and messing around, but they did some light contributing/scumhunting here and there too but not as much as I would like them to. They said that they didn’t like everyone piling on Bella like that, and wanted to start a “counter wagon” with Broncos, which I think is something worth noting considering Bella turned out to be mafia. This leads me to think they might be buddies (Bella & Rosey, not Rosey & Broncos although that may be possible too). However, I don’t exactly know how they usually play, because this is my first game with them so I’m unsure on what to think. They haven’t really done anything scummy other than that and most of their other posts seems townish to me. This is subject to change as Rosey posts more, but for now I’m going with - Unsure, Maybe Town? 54.578/45.422 (54 was not enough but 55 was too much
)~Lala: Has been one of the most active players on both days 1 and 2. Has scumhunted and contributed the most as well, which makes me give her lots of towncred. Lala is kind of hard to read in general, and it doesn’t make it any better that the only game I’ve played where she was scum, she acted basically identical to how she usually plays as town. But she hasn’t done or said anything that strikes me as scummy, and that combined with the towncred & her activity makes me go with - Leaning Town 70/30
~Frenchy: Was not that active on day 1 and hasn’t talked yet today. Has not scumhunted nor contributed either. I really did not like their wacky self vote & their reasoning for changing their vote to Ham, which you can see for yourself here:
Something that I think is worth noting is that Ham actually posted their post BEFORE Frenchy posted, so their reasoning about it being a crazy coincidence that both of them said what they said and that one of them might be scum is pretty odd. I want to hear more from them because they are one of the only players who haven’t contributed yet. But something about them irks me and the reasoning post seems like a rushed coverup as to why they voted for someone to try and save their potential partner (Bella). This is subject to change as Frenchy starts posting more and if they defend themselves, but for now I’m going with - Leaning Scum 45/55
~Broncos: Was fairly active on day 1 and hasn’t been online as of yet today. From what I can remember, I think they were lightly scumhunting & contributing here and there. After Bella turned out to be scum and I was reading through the posts, their vote on Frenchy while there were many votes on Bella seemed odd to me. It felt like they were trying to start a counter-wagon on a new player who isn’t able to defend themselves properly to try and get the townies to come over so they can save their buddy. Broncos is just hard to read in general and it doesn’t make it better that I’ve only played a few games with them and I don’t know their playstyle. Again, this is subject to change as they start posting more & defending themselves, but for now I’m going with - Leaning Scum? 45/55
~Choco: Has been pretty active on both days 1 and 2, and has contributed a lot, which makes me give them some towncred. I didn’t like how they started thinking I’m scum seemingly just because I questioned them yesterday, and it made me rethink my read on him. Although their explanations as to why they said the things they said seems genuine & townish to me, and I’m inclined to trust them because they’re one of those people who always seem town (e.g Keyen, Dekay). The list that they made:
1. Sophia - Neutral ground, leaning scum, the way she plays this game reminds me of her Arianna alter-ego in Keyen's anon game but could theoretically speaking, playing as town trying to make an effort in scumhunting, in which case makes her appear townish in my book at the same time. I'm actually unsure about her.
2. Keyen - Neutral ground, seems quite normal to me as of now, I honestly don't think I remember how mafia keyen acted.
3. City - Neutral ground, seems like a genuine mafia magnet who's tired of shizzle 'n stuff and I know that sucks. But she need to come up and say hi to us before she gets herself whacked.
4. Luna - Neutral ground, leaning town, nothing exactly stood out to me but I've always town-read Luna by default. She seems active enough so I'll give her that for the time being.
5. Bella - Neutral ground, leaning scum, that reply to Lala kinda rubbed me the wrong way, but it is mostly a gut-feeling and instinct rather than any concrete evidence. And I hate it when I am relying on something so feeble to suspect someone because if I were you, Bella, I would feel really bummed as if everyone just seems to find anything I said as scummy.
6. Skelda - Normal ground, leaning town, seems to actively scum hunt and raising suspicions on anything he could gather. Other than that, nothing stood out to me as unordinary.
7: Scherzo - Neutral ground, possibly leaning scum, I forgot to add him to the list I made earlier. Don't think he's posted yet. Same as City, I always find him sus regardless of his alignment.
7: Scherzo - Neutral ground, possibly leaning scum, I forgot to add him to the list I made earlier. Don't think he's posted yet. Same as City, I always find him sus regardless of his alignment.
8: Rosey - Normal ground, leaning town, same as Skelda, nothing weird stood out to me yet.
9: Lala - Normal ground, leaning town, I dunno. Lala is always a hard one to read and I often give her the benefit of the doubt even when she's mafia. She can be tricky, too. But she seems very comfortable with where the game is heading as of now so she's okay in my book.
10: Frenchy - Normal ground, possibly leaning scum, relatively new to the game (I think?) and seems quite timid about 'angering' players for posting them. Conservative attitude reminds me of when I first played mafia, regardless of alignment. Free pass issued.
11: Ham - Normal ground, possibly leaning scum, same as Frenchy above, shared their reserved attitude. Could be bad but not with Frenchy.
12: Broncos - Normal ground, said something that appeared as neither scummy nor townish to me. Could be avoiding the drama without others pointing out that she's been too quiet to their liking. But then other than that nothing much to go on.
13: Choco - "Portuguese Daddy" is my alter ego.
12: Broncos - Normal ground, said something that appeared as neither scummy nor townish to me. Could be avoiding the drama without others pointing out that she's been too quiet to their liking. But then other than that nothing much to go on.
13: Choco - "Portuguese Daddy" is my alter ego.
??
