|
|
Post by choco on Jun 20, 2020 4:45:35 GMT -5
She probably meant she got one of the town PRs that she personally didn’t enjoy using? I know a number of players here wouldn’t like it if they picked vigilante. I think it is possible that she did indeed flip scum solely based on the existence of that reply alone but I’m pretty sure only she knows what she meant by that. This is sketch. Explain? I thought the way she phrased her reply to your question as "it could be worse, it could be better" was weird because it is something she would likely say if she's really got a role as mafia, or if she's got a town PR role that carries a lot of responsibility. Bella's reply was odd and probably the only thing she said this whole game that caught my attention, as I have explained in that list I posted minutes before the flip, and I am sorry because I wasn't checking the time and didn't know day would end anytime soon. It was merely a vote based on gut-feeling, which is what I usually go with the first day, especially that other players in comparison didn't act in an eerie way that made me suspect them. And Broncos, I don't know. Tbh, I kinda forgot that she was playing this game. I don't think she said anything that was memorable to me. |
|
|
|
Post by choco on Jun 20, 2020 4:47:21 GMT -5
I also haven't seen Bronx and Choco interact together You haven't interacted a number of players either, same as I, because they were inactive. I was waiting for them to return and expecting to engage with them more from D2 onwards. |
|
|
|
Post by Lala on Jun 20, 2020 4:52:47 GMT -5
Explain? I thought the way she phrased her reply to your question as "it could be worse, it could be better" was weird because it is something she would likely say if she's really got a role as mafia, or if she's got a town PR role that carries a lot of responsibility. Bella's reply was odd and probably the only thing she said this whole game that caught my attention, as I have explained in that list I posted minutes before the flip, and I am sorry because I wasn't checking the time and didn't know day would end anytime soon. It was merely a vote based on gut-feeling, which is what I usually go with the first day, especially that other players in comparison didn't act in an eerie way that made me suspect them. And Broncos, I don't know. Tbh, I kinda forgot that she was playing this game. I don't think she said anything that was memorable to me. I think it is sketch because I don't think anyone who got a PR role or a town role in general would ever say "it could be better." Especially coming from Bella. It is sketch because you were defending her about her quote and making what seems to be excuses for her. I hope that makes sense. |
|
|
|
Post by choco on Jun 20, 2020 4:55:04 GMT -5
A tracker might have been chosen, but that doesn't seem like a good choice to me compare to vigilante because why throw away your chance to shoot anyone you suspect every night? That way you get to have 1 less people to be suspicious of and make it easier for town to scumhunt. Not to mention that investigative roles (psychologist or detective) and weak hider targeting people can easily confuse the tracker.
I think it's likely that vigilante's lying low after seeing that their intended target didn't die last night, probably because they hid behind a townie or that they were jailed. This is what most likely happened, me thinks.
|
|
|
|
Post by Lala on Jun 20, 2020 5:00:16 GMT -5
That's what I was thinking, some active that went into the scum chat and was like hey y'all might wanna post please and thank you. They don't know what to say, so they say they don't know what's going on? I would love it if this was true but I doubt it is. I feel like the more active scum would include DON'T POST AT THE SAME in the message poking them. That could potentially be the case, but if they were both scum (extra emphasise on were, as I don't see how as of now) it would be too obvious that they came up and commented in such similar tones one after the other. But it can also just be two townies returning and posting on the site around same time unintentionally. Probably just coincidence, I personally don't think both of them (probably one is town, the possibility of both being mafia is less likely to me) are bad. Feels like I'm issuing new, inactive players a free pass quite easily this time and that is not sitting too well to myself.  Interaction between Broncos and Choco here, and I have to say I think this sounds pretty town. I'm more for Broncos/Rosey at this point than Broncos/Choco. It would have been very easy for Choco if he were mafia to slide either Ham or Frenchy into the wall (at least if he were partnered with Bronocs). For what it's worth, Broncos seemed to be supporting them, too. Ya -- I don't know. I want to hear from Rosey and Broncos. And I want City (who might see things with fresh eyes since she was absent yesterday) to give her thoughts. Sometimes new eyes see things differently. |
|
|
|
Post by Lala on Jun 20, 2020 5:01:20 GMT -5
A tracker might have been chosen, but that doesn't seem like a good choice to me compare to vigilante because why throw away your chance to shoot anyone you suspect every night? That way you get to have 1 less people to be suspicious of and make it easier for town to scumhunt. Not to mention that investigative roles (psychologist or detective) and weak hider targeting people can easily confuse the tracker. I think it's likely that vigilante's lying low after seeing that their intended target didn't die last night, probably because they hid behind a townie or that they were jailed. This is what most likely happened, me thinks. As much fun as vigilante can be, I'd still pick tracker over vig this game. Probably about a 50/50 shot (no pun intended) someone picked vig. |
|
|
|
Post by Lala on Jun 20, 2020 5:03:52 GMT -5
Chocobeans, what is your opinion on the Roseybeard right now? I know in the past you've said townish or neutralish.
Are you still thinking Sophia is scummy?
|
|
|
|
Post by choco on Jun 20, 2020 5:07:05 GMT -5
Explain? I thought the way she phrased her reply to your question as "it could be worse, it could be better" was weird because it is something she would likely say if she's really got a role as mafia, or if she's got a town PR role that carries a lot of responsibility. Bella's reply was odd and probably the only thing she said this whole game that caught my attention, as I have explained in that list I posted minutes before the flip, and I am sorry because I wasn't checking the time and didn't know day would end anytime soon. It was merely a vote based on gut-feeling, which is what I usually go with the first day, especially that other players in comparison didn't act in an eerie way that made me suspect them. And Broncos, I don't know. Tbh, I kinda forgot that she was playing this game. I don't think she said anything that was memorable to me. I think it is sketch because I don't think anyone who got a PR role or a town role in general would ever say "it could be better." Especially coming from Bella. It is sketch because you were defending her about her quote and making what seems to be excuses for her. I hope that makes sense. I was defending her because I thought she could still be good. I am not her so I wouldn't know if she's got her own preference for town PR. Personally I would think that a "hider" role is not as good as an investigative role or a vigilante role and if that's what I got from Zinnia, I would also think: "Oh yeah, that role is okay, but it could be better (if I got a psychologist/detective role) or could be worse (if I got a scum role)." Yeah, I am not going to lie that I was defending her but I felt like she deserved to have another chance of being in the game for longer, consider how she got voted out because of her inactivity in Keyen's anon game. Lala, you replaced her so you probably know how it felt like to be whacked when you were not mafia. And in many previous games I've played with Bella, she was whacked quite early in the game because of, you guessed it, her inactivity. Sure, she had been whacked that way in either alignments, and it was possible that she could flip scum or otherwise this time but at that time I was trying to understand her reasoning behind making that one comment and wondered if that's what I would think of my role too if I were in her shoes. I was glad and disappointed when she flipped scum, it felt like she's never truly invested in a game of mafia regardless of her alignment. |
|
|
|
Post by choco on Jun 20, 2020 5:09:10 GMT -5
Chocobeans, what is your opinion on the Roseybeard right now? I know in the past you've said townish or neutralish. Are you still thinking Sophia is scummy? I'm still waiting on that list she was making but failed to post. Rosey is a tricky one, I've played with her on and off since 2018 and still can't read her whatsoever. I need more stuff from both of them to mull over before I can make up my mind. |
|
|
|
Post by Lala on Jun 20, 2020 5:14:14 GMT -5
With Rosey, when I think she's town she's mafia and when I think she's mafia, she's town.
So...I understand completely.
|
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Jun 20, 2020 5:14:15 GMT -5
Mafia knew Skelda was town and bumped him off, yet Keyen suspected Lala a little this morning, when she was basically in the same boat as Skelda. That’s a point for Keyen.
|
|
|
|
Post by Lala on Jun 20, 2020 5:14:58 GMT -5
I'm irritated they killed Skelda. It's a rare game we are on the same page early on.
|
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Jun 20, 2020 5:17:41 GMT -5
Bella/Choco/Rosey OR Bella/Choco/Broncos HMMMMM, my bets are on the latter Not a bad thought. The second one I mean. There’s also the quiet people who could also be scum. Since Choco and Broncos were active and posting it is more likely that they’ll have made sketchy posts, not to discount those sketchy posts’ existence. |
|
nicki
Queen of Rap 
naughtynicki
super freaky girl
Posts: 6,986
|
Post by nicki on Jun 20, 2020 5:19:04 GMT -5
Explain? I thought the way she phrased her reply to your question as "it could be worse, it could be better" was weird because it is something she would likely say if she's really got a role as mafia, or if she's got a town PR role that carries a lot of responsibility. Bella's reply was odd and probably the only thing she said this whole game that caught my attention, as I have explained in that list I posted minutes before the flip, and I am sorry because I wasn't checking the time and didn't know day would end anytime soon. It was merely a vote based on gut-feeling, which is what I usually go with the first day, especially that other players in comparison didn't act in an eerie way that made me suspect them. And Broncos, I don't know. Tbh, I kinda forgot that she was playing this game. I don't think she said anything that was memorable to me. It doesn't make sense to say something like that if you're a Town PR. Wouldn't you be smart enough to say something like "I'm town" as PR than say something that could hurt town? Broncos has said many things that could help you have a read on her. |
|
|
|
Post by choco on Jun 20, 2020 5:20:12 GMT -5
This post from Bella irritates me, the way she jumps on Choco. I could see her as scum, especially if Choco isn't. More info is needed. I wasn't necessarily saying he was scum, just saying I'm not sure how to read him yet. I've played with her a while back (probably almost a year ago or so) and she did really well at catching me as scum the first day, which means she's definitely capable of reading me as town. So I didn't buy what she said about the bolded part at all. |
|
