|
Post by DeKay on Feb 6, 2020 9:11:58 GMT -5
Why not Iceman then? Just asking. I still think Iceman can be town. My only suspect for now is Rosey. But like I said, I think it's a Rosey-Iceman scumteam. If you're actually town, then it's def Icey and Rosey cuz it ain't me. �
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Feb 6, 2020 9:50:54 GMT -5
It’s good to see you by the way, Dekay. We haven’t played together in what feels like forever.
Speaking of forever, is this day going to end? I ran out of on-topic things to say 48 hours ago. The way I see it it’s either Zinnia/Fresh, Zinnia/Keyen, or Fresh/Keyen. I was thinking it probably wasn’t Zinnia/Fresh due to how Fresh was voting Zinnia day one, and my general townread on her unreplaced absence. I guess Bella felt the need to replace her though so maybe that metagame read was wrong, though she seemed fine at the time. Fresh voted Keyen which put him into a hammer (if we had been doing hammers), which could mean a number of things. Either he was doing a final bus on a scumbuddy, or a quickhammer on a townie, or just a townish vote made in impatience. Hopefully it wasn’t option 2, but I can’t see how it would be unless he’s scum with Zinnia.
I’m pretty sure I want to keep my vote. I haven’t really been townreading Keyen this game, and my most likely hypothetical scum teams all include him.
|
|
|
Post by bellagorilla on Feb 6, 2020 11:31:40 GMT -5
So it's currently 10:30am central standard time... Would everyone be conformable if I set a deadline for 10pm tonight?
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Feb 6, 2020 12:05:58 GMT -5
That’s fine by me
|
|
|
Post by DeKay on Feb 6, 2020 17:37:06 GMT -5
It’s good to see you by the way, Dekay. We haven’t played together in what feels like forever. Speaking of forever, is this day going to end? I ran out of on-topic things to say 48 hours ago. The way I see it it’s either Zinnia/Fresh, Zinnia/Keyen, or Fresh/Keyen. I was thinking it probably wasn’t Zinnia/Fresh due to how Fresh was voting Zinnia day one, and my general townread on her unreplaced absence. I guess Bella felt the need to replace her though so maybe that metagame read was wrong, though she seemed fine at the time. Fresh voted Keyen which put him into a hammer (if we had been doing hammers), which could mean a number of things. Either he was doing a final bus on a scumbuddy, or a quickhammer on a townie, or just a townish vote made in impatience. Hopefully it wasn’t option 2, but I can’t see how it would be unless he’s scum with Zinnia. I’m pretty sure I want to keep my vote. I haven’t really been townreading Keyen this game, and my most likely hypothetical scum teams all include him. Hi! Good to see you too. Now, on to me scum reading you. LOL. Hmm, this just seems to me that you are fake suspecting Icey in your hypothetical scum teams. You have Icey in 2 of your scum teams and you also have Keyen in 2 but you still decide to choose Keyen anyway. You also have me in 2. I understand that having to pick the more possible bad guy when you have 3 people in the same number of mafia teams is hard but the way you picked it doesn't seem like a very townie way of thinking, in my opinion. First of all, I don't think town Icey would make a quick vote on Keyen out of impatience cuz I believe town will lose today if Keyen flips Town. But yeah, it's possible that he could be Keyen's scum buddy and is bussing him. Tho, looking at Keyen's posts, he doesn't seem so mafiaish (unless he's really this confused all the time or pretends to be confused as mafia). Does he do that? Cuz he keeps on not knowing that Lala is town. Which I believe Lala is, since she was not revealed as mafia goon and day goes on, right? So with my reading for these two people and if I were you, I would have picked Icey cuz he seems like a better scummy option. Plus, you also think that Icey and I are scum or Keyen and I are scum, but why not vote me? I mean, Icey can also just vote me (Zinnia) on day 1 quickly just for fun cuz he knows he's gonna take it out anyways. I wasn't there when it happened but it didn't look to me that he was holding that Zinnia vote for very long, so to me it didn't really seem like bussing. I do have to look back and see the timestamps tho. Also, another thing about Icey is that he tends to ask people or their opinions alot in this game and then going by their opinion/suspicions. I think town Icey is usually better at forming his own suspicions first. But it's been a while since I played with him so I could be wrong. I'm just looking at all of this in a general point of view of my experience playing mafia tho. And to me, Icey looks scummier than Keyen. But the reason why I'm voting you still is to make you get two votes. Now if only Lala could switch her vote to you, that will be great. Cuz I also think you're scum.
|
|
|
Post by Lala on Feb 6, 2020 17:58:21 GMT -5
I'm town
|
|
|
Post by Lala on Feb 6, 2020 18:01:04 GMT -5
Plus, I think it's Iceman/Keyen.
I could be wrong. Rosey triscks me a lot. I was not worried about Zinnia at all so I'm not worried about DeKay, either.
Iceman doesn't want to vote Keyen and Keyen doesn't want to vote Iceman. If I were scum, I"d be hesitant to vote for my partner, too ... even if it meant sacrificing the win.
I will only vote Iceman or Keyen today. And I die anyway, so I won't vote tomorrow.
It's not if you win or lose, it's how you play the game -- and I think Keyen and Iceman are doing the admirable thing. Kudos for them even though they are mafia together.
So ... watch it be Rosey and Dekay because I'm bad at this, lol.
|
|
|
Post by bellagorilla on Feb 6, 2020 20:46:54 GMT -5
Day Two Vote History: Lala v. Keyen Keyen v. Rosey Rosey v. Keyen Icey v. Keyen DeKay v. Rosey Keyen (3) - Lala, Rosey, Icey Rosey (2) - Keyen, DeKay Do keep in mind that Lala dies alongside the whack today! So choose your whack wisely. *DeKay replaced Zinnia So if we're running with a 10pm deadline, that means y'all have another 2 hours and 15-ish minutes. Still good with everyone?
|
|
|
Post by DeKay on Feb 6, 2020 20:46:54 GMT -5
Plus, I think it's Iceman/Keyen. I could be wrong. Rosey triscks me a lot. I was not worried about Zinnia at all so I'm not worried about DeKay, either. Iceman doesn't want to vote Keyen and Keyen doesn't want to vote Iceman. If I were scum, I"d be hesitant to vote for my partner, too ... even if it meant sacrificing the win. I will only vote Iceman or Keyen today. And I die anyway, so I won't vote tomorrow. It's not if you win or lose, it's how you play the game -- and I think Keyen and Iceman are doing the admirable thing. Kudos for them even though they are mafia together. So ... watch it be Rosey and Dekay because I'm bad at this, lol. Haha, if Keyen is really scum, then he really did fool me. Good for him. I can see how Icey does look like he was a bit hesitant to vote Keyen with his "we'll see how this goes", but it could also go either way.
|
|
|
Post by DeKay on Feb 6, 2020 20:47:30 GMT -5
Day Two Vote History: Lala v. Keyen Keyen v. Rosey Rosey v. Keyen Icey v. Keyen DeKay v. Rosey Keyen (3) - Lala, Rosey, Icey Rosey (2) - Keyen, DeKay Do keep in mind that Lala dies alongside the whack today! So choose your whack wisely. *DeKay replaced Zinnia So if we're running with a 10pm deadline, that means y'all have another 2 hours and 15-ish minutes. Still good with everyone? Yeah, I guess. I don't think the rest are gonna come on in time anyways.
|
|
|
Post by bellagorilla on Feb 6, 2020 20:49:51 GMT -5
So if we're running with a 10pm deadline, that means y'all have another 2 hours and 15-ish minutes. Still good with everyone? Yeah, I guess. I don't think the rest are gonna come on in time anyways. If you'd like more time, I don't mind extending day at all, but I most likely won't be up much past 10pm (I have an 8:30am class ).
|
|
|
Post by DeKay on Feb 6, 2020 20:51:14 GMT -5
Keyen, you know I'm not scum. Although it does throw me off a bit since Rosey voted you, lol. I may have to reconsider things later. Zinnia and Iceman what say you? Why do you think Rosey and Keyen are the Mafia? Just a gut feeling? And I think Keyen does have a point. I think his vote on Lala does seem like a genuine town vote. I haven't played in a while though, so I've kind of forgotten how some people play. Zinnia and Rosey I'm 50/50 on. So far, we have 3 votes with Keyen leading, but I'm not fully convinced it's him. If I have to choose right now, I'd go with Vote: LalaSorry if I'm wrong :0 I just think this post from Icey is a bit too "defensive" on Keyen. If they were both buddies, I think Icey would have not made it look so obvious like he was trying to save him. 3 votes on someone in a small game is huge. He would have just let it slide and low key bussed Keyen at this point, I think.
|
|
|
Post by DeKay on Feb 6, 2020 20:52:35 GMT -5
Yeah, I guess. I don't think the rest are gonna come on in time anyways. If you'd like more time, I don't mind extending day at all, but I most likely won't be up much past 10pm (I have an 8:30am class ). It's okay. It's been more than 24 hours since I joined and I did not even get to talk to Icey or Keyen much. So I don't think it will make a difference.
|
|
|
Post by bellagorilla on Feb 6, 2020 23:03:17 GMT -5
]Day Two Vote History: Lala v. Keyen Keyen v. Rosey Rosey v. Keyen Icey v. Keyen DeKay v. Rosey Keyen (3) - Lala, Rosey, Icey Rosey (2) - Keyen, DeKay Do keep in mind that Lala dies alongside the whack today! So choose your whack wisely. *DeKay replaced Zinnia And with that, Keyen has been whacked. Lala dies alongside him. Two innocent townies have died today. That means the two mafia remain, and one last town...so mafia win! Rosey was the mafia Godfather. Icey was the mafia goon. DeKay/Zinnia was the remaining townie. Thanks for playing guys!
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Feb 6, 2020 23:19:13 GMT -5
GG.
Thanks for hosting, Bella.
|
|