[ti]day[/ti]It's a Mafia Game! Town Wins! - Page 51

I actually have a thing from 9-1 tomorrow that I kind of forgot about so I won't be online during that time. Sorry, hopefully I don't miss a ton. I imagine it will probably be the end of Day 1 and the start of Day 2 during that time.

So whack Legend, failing that whack Rosey is what I'd say. And this is a friendly reminder to the scum that I've died Night 1 the past two times and would very much appreciate it if you weren't tacky and didn't kill me again.

i'm really sorry for my absence!! school just started again and i've been really busy. but i have read through and here are my thoughts!:

1. Rosey: i can never read rosey well, but they seem town so far. however, i always seem to say this, and then, later on, i start to regret it...
2. Tribbo: tribbo!
3. Legend: i don't see legend as scum this game. his disagreement with sjappie just seemed to stem from him being tired of dying early on lol. i didn't really understand both of their points. they seemed to be basing it off playstyles, yet both were accusing each other of being wrong. reading the disagreement was confusing, lol. all i really got from it was that it was simply just two townies sparring, lol.
4. Fairy: undecided. need to hear more.
5. Kitty: she did vote for lala almost right away. she wasn't hesitant about it at all. maybe good, but i need to hear more.
6. Skelda: his vote on lala was quick. i don't know what to think of that. lala says she believes he is town, but i'm not sure. undecided?
7. Lala: her frustration reminds me of last game
8. Apple: she voted legend although nobody seemed to be suspicious of him. her reasoning seemed good before legend justified himself, lol. but, again, i think they are both just two townies that are butting heads.
9. Katie: undecided, but she did just vote, unvote, and go. i think she did that last game and she was good, but i haven't heard enough from her to say for sure
10. Bella: undecided. need to hear more.

A MAFIA GAME, AN ESSAY:
Here follows a player by player analysis of their posts so far. I will be looking at inconsistencies, reactions and general playstyle.
First things first. We have 5 hours to figure this out… Zinnia said so in the very first post. (24 hours, 19 hours ago)
1. Rosey
Rosey’s first post is… Rosey… Means nothing. (Page 3)
Rosey’s second post, asking whether I’m sure can hardly be read as a serious request. I think she knows that I just posted that for the heck of it. (Page 3)
Rosey being tempted to Vote Lala is normal. (Page 3)
2. Tribbo
3. Legend
My first post doesn’t indicate anything. It says: I’m innocent… That’s not even a side claim. IF ANYTHING that’s a soft hint at guardian angel, which I assure you I am NOT. (Page 2)
My reaction to Rosey is the only logical reaction. Nothing wrong there. (Page 3)
My Lala vote was bad. I should not have done that. I was joking around too much. (Page 3)
LEGEND STOP TROLLING EARLY GAME YOU FECKING FECK (Page 4)
Yes! Good read on Katie. That vote is scumsided. Good boy! (Page 4)
Why do you act fine with Sjappie’s vote when you immediately were like: That’s not right. You nobhead. (Page 4)
Tries to get a read on Bella. Is probably right that she’s town. (Page 7)



4. Fairy
Emzy liked Lala’s first derailing posts and was very happy to react to my trolling yesterday. Emzy and I often do things somewhat similarly and I think keeping up the derailing is a good tactic. (Page 2)
The derailing continues… (Page 3)
And continues with a joking Lala vote. (Page 3)
Trying for a Kitty suspicion after either a confirmed joke or a town sided Vote… Is scummy. (Page 3)
Emzy… continues… derailing….. (Page 4)
CHRIST EMZY. STOP DERAILING (Page 5)

5. Kitty
Having seen the first derailing post and then seeing a vote on Lala makes a lot of sense to me. I am reading Kitty’s first vote as VERY town despite her seemingly agreeing with it a revenge vote. (Page 3)
Kitty jokingly asks for forgiveness. I read this as town. (Page 3)
Kitty rightfully reads into my bad Lala vote. Very Town. (Page 4)
Kitty continues confirming that it was a joke. I think she buys Lala’s frustration. (Page 5) (Page 7)
Kitty Agrees that leaving the ANGEL is a good thing. Town (Page 5)

6. Skelda
Immediately begins by voting Lala which is an amazing TOWN vote at this point. I love this vote from Skelda. Very townish and to the point, like we know him. I agree with his reasoning as well. 10/10. (Page 5)
Skelda is confused about the host. That’s not right. Very unlike him… Not scummish, just weird.(Page 5)
Skelda sticks to his vote. Good. Town. Loving your reasoning. (Page 5) (Page 7)

7. Lala
Her first posts are immediately derailing from the game. She usually plays safer when scum but these posts are probably a good indicator that she has scumpotential. (Page 2)
Lala claiming that Kitty’s vote is a revenge vote from last game… Has scumpotential, again. (Page 3)
Lala’s Faux bait-setting after the unvote has scumpotential due to inconsistently with the last post where she clearly said NO to it. (Page 3)
Lala… Is frustrated THIS EARLY? At CLEAR joke votes?... *BEEP* SCUMRADAR* Also… the threat of self-voting to get out of things is getting old. I’ll let you kill yourself one of these days. (Page 4)
Lala agrees with the Kitty vote being townish even though her voting started the Lala bandwagon. The frustration therefore is fake. Stop doing that. (Page 4)
I really don’t get why everyone is reading into the I’m innocent post so much. I must be missing something. I like Lala’s idea of me omitting the truth. The problem is: I’d lie. I would also just say: I’m town if I meant anything by it. I think no one would have batted an eye if I did that. (Page 4)
The suicide threat continues… as well as the Faux frustration. I don’t like this tactic. SCUM (Page 5)
See above. (Page 5)


8. Apple (Here we go…)
Start of page 4… She greets everyone. No suspicion for anything yet, at least not shown. (Page 4)
It takes Sjappie at least a full hour and Lala poking at my Innocent post again before she finds it suspicious. Then she immediately admits to breaking pattern to vote me. … I actually agree with her vote at this point, but not for the reasons she is stating. (Page 4)

Doesn’t seem to care too much about the Legend vote and is willing to keep me around… Oh Flubber knuckles . (Page 7)


9. Katie
Katie doesn’t reply immediately to the derailing question. This is good in my books. Townish? (Page 4)

Katie votes Kitty… I don’t agree with this. More scum sided action.

10. Bella
Bella’s Neutral reaction after the bait-setting after the unvote has scum potential in my books. Neutral reactions work well against bait. (Page 3)
Bella reacts neutral to Emzy’s suspicion. It seems more town-sided this time, though. (Page 3)
Bella’s reaction to the Lala Bandwagon is alright. She WOULD jump on this. (Page 6)
Bella confirms she’s town and therefore is town… that’s how this works, right? (Page 7)


TLDR: I have been reading up until page 8 when Bumbo hit the fan.
I have Misread SJAPPIE GREATLY. HER REASONING IS SOLID AND HER VOTE ON ME IS GOOD AS WELL.

I THINK YOU SHOULD LOOK INTO LaLa and EMZY if anyone. EMZY over Lala.

UNVOTE

No. Kitty is town. I'd rather die.

My essay says differently.

If you vote Kitty then we only need one more vote.

Well, I am.