|
|
Post by ApplelovePear on Aug 12, 2018 4:02:10 GMT -5
I am now. Vote: LegendYou're too erratic for my likings, you haven't helped us in any way. Then it'll be like IRL all over again... "Kill him before he pulls his mind games, I don't like it" <--- Don'trememberwhosaidthat And an addendum to my previous post: - I correctly believed Zinnia on her fruit-bearer claim. That could have been helpful. I'd like to know what you would want from me? I thought I was able to use my role in every way I see fit, right? If I think healing myself is the correct play, then I should be allowed to heal myself. I don't care what you all think is the right way of playing roles is "Shouldn't have claimed", "Shouldn't heal yourself that's what scum does", "You're useless" You know what you are doing right know? You are willingly and knowlingly whacking a townie because he doesn't play by YOUR rules. Lol, that's nice and manipulative, shame I don't fall for it. If I had claimed some sort of role day 1 and just yolo'd it I bet you would've gone after me, because to your mind it's scum behaviour. That's how this game works. And you can't say it's like RL all over again, in RL you get killed day 1 or night 1 out of fear. I didn't want to whack you day 1, I didn't want to do it yesterday, but you haven't done anything to get some towncred, so I suspect you. That's as easy as it is  |
|
|
|
Post by HungryPony27 on Aug 12, 2018 4:02:13 GMT -5
Then it'll be like IRL all over again... "Kill him before he pulls his mind games, I don't like it" <--- Don'trememberwhosaidthat And an addendum to my previous post: - I correctly believed Zinnia on her fruit-bearer claim. That could have been helpful. I'd like to know what you would want from me? I thought I was able to use my role in every way I see fit, right? If I think healing myself is the correct play, then I should be allowed to heal myself. I don't care what you all think is the right way of playing roles is "Shouldn't have claimed", "Shouldn't heal yourself that's what scum does", "You're useless" You know what you are doing right know? You are willingly and knowlingly whacking a townie because he doesn't play by YOUR rules. Hey, uh-uh, no laying a trip. Bad Legend. Sad! Not meant as a trip. It's meant as a wake-up call. I don't see the point of killing a townie even if they're not good enough for your standards. |
|
|
|
Post by ApplelovePear on Aug 12, 2018 4:05:53 GMT -5
Hey, uh-uh, no laying a trip. Bad Legend. Sad! Not meant as a trip. It's meant as a wake-up call. I don't see the point of killing a townie even if they're not good enough for your standards. So how do I determain scum if not by their disability to help town? Also, if Alleen comes with something convincing I might still unvote you, but your posts make you the top of my scumlist. So I vote you. |
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Aug 12, 2018 4:05:54 GMT -5
Rosey why do you want to lunch Skelda? Any particular reason? No magical reason, but he doesn’t seem town to me. The only whack he has pushed for is mine, that’s not like him. And it’s beginning to seem as if he has no reason to suspect me. He’s just pushing for me. He believed Legend’s claim rather quickly, almost like a scum wanting to get in the doctor’s good graces. My first instinct was that it was a post restriction for Legend— that he had to claim upon being voted. He just jumped straight to the trusting and that pinged quite a few people. He hasn’t been completely natural either. He is different from his town play. Very present, but saying nothing new. He’s made a few generic observations, such as justifying Legend’s claim, but they are very neutral. And finally, every time I suggest whacking him I get completely, entirely, and flat-out ignored. That suggests scum. |
|
|
|
Post by HungryPony27 on Aug 12, 2018 4:07:57 GMT -5
Then it'll be like IRL all over again... "Kill him before he pulls his mind games, I don't like it" <--- Don'trememberwhosaidthat And an addendum to my previous post: - I correctly believed Zinnia on her fruit-bearer claim. That could have been helpful. I'd like to know what you would want from me? I thought I was able to use my role in every way I see fit, right? If I think healing myself is the correct play, then I should be allowed to heal myself. I don't care what you all think is the right way of playing roles is "Shouldn't have claimed", "Shouldn't heal yourself that's what scum does", "You're useless" You know what you are doing right know? You are willingly and knowlingly whacking a townie because he doesn't play by YOUR rules. Lol, that's nice and manipulative, shame I don't fall for it. If I had claimed some sort of role day 1 and just yolo'd it I bet you would've gone after me, because to your mind it's scum behaviour. That's how this game works. And you can't say it's like RL all over again, in RL you get killed day 1 or night 1 out of fear. I didn't want to whack you day 1, I didn't want to do it yesterday, but you haven't done anything to get some towncred, so I suspect you. That's as easy as it is  Except that's not how you've mentioned it the last few posts. If that's what this is all about then you should have said that straight away and I would have let it rest. Rather than saying that you seemed to bash the way I play doctor. But is the fact that Katie's kill didn't go through enough towncred to leave me be for at least the day? It should be. And no, in some cases the day 1 claim is very legitimate in my eyes. I made the conscious decision between death and playing doctor openly. It would have been so MUCH WORSE if I was dead right now because I genuinely believe that without my claim I would have been whacked day 1. I was at 3 votes at 1 point and the day 1 whack ended up winning with 3 votes. Besides, Look at the sheer amount of mafia carnage that's going on. We have only lost the one townie so far. Someone is doing something very right, now aren't day? |
|
|
|
Post by HungryPony27 on Aug 12, 2018 4:14:26 GMT -5
Not meant as a trip. It's meant as a wake-up call. I don't see the point of killing a townie even if they're not good enough for your standards. So how do I determain scum if not by their disability to help town? Also, if Alleen comes with something convincing I might still unvote you, but your posts make you the top of my scumlist. So I vote you. - By reading into their posts and seeing what they're not saying rather than what they are saying for someone can very well lie in their words but will always subconsciously point out the truth in one way or another. Noone is a perfect liar. - By looking at previous games and seeing how their behaviour was and seeing if the patterns align or not. - By looking at whackes, the results and the ways the roles seem to have been used and thereby deducting scum. - By aggressively poking at someone until they slip up. - By looking at what everyone else believes and cross-examining that with your own thoughts. - POE To name a few? Funny thing is, I like pointing town towards the scum if I am scum. I do it at least once every game. My previous mafia buddies can attest to that. Especially Zinnia, but she's dead. |
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Aug 12, 2018 4:15:08 GMT -5
Vote: Skelda
Come on, lovelies, you know it makes sense.
|
|
|
|
Post by ApplelovePear on Aug 12, 2018 4:15:27 GMT -5
Lol, that's nice and manipulative, shame I don't fall for it. If I had claimed some sort of role day 1 and just yolo'd it I bet you would've gone after me, because to your mind it's scum behaviour. That's how this game works. And you can't say it's like RL all over again, in RL you get killed day 1 or night 1 out of fear. I didn't want to whack you day 1, I didn't want to do it yesterday, but you haven't done anything to get some towncred, so I suspect you. That's as easy as it is Except that's not how you've mentioned it the last few posts. If that's what this is all about then you should have said that straight away and I would have let it rest. Rather than saying that you seemed to bash the way I play doctor. But is the fact that Katie's kill didn't go through enough towncred to leave me be for at least the day? It should be. And no, in some cases the day 1 claim is very legitimate in my eyes. I made the conscious decision between death and playing doctor openly. It would have been so MUCH WORSE if I was dead right now because I genuinely believe that without my claim I would have been whacked day 1. I was at 3 votes at 1 point and the day 1 whack ended up winning with 3 votes. Besides, Look at the sheer amount of mafia carnage that's going on. We have only lost the one townie so far. Someone is doing something very right, now aren't day? Why else would I be stating those reasons if I wouldn't think you are scum? You really think I'd go after you if I didn't think you were scum? What would be the use of that? Also you wouldn't have been whacked if you had simply said I have a very powerful role that I don't wish to reveal yet. Or just wait and see because it's never the first one on the block who gets whacked in these big games. I also only remember Skelda voting you. Anyway, there's many townier ways you could've handled it. |
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Aug 12, 2018 4:16:10 GMT -5
|
|
|
|
Post by ApplelovePear on Aug 12, 2018 4:21:23 GMT -5
Vote: SkeldaCome on, lovelies, you know it makes sense. I don't know Rosey, there's too many people scummier in my opinion at this point. I don't want to vote him yet |
|
|
|
Post by HungryPony27 on Aug 12, 2018 4:22:52 GMT -5
Vote: SkeldaCome on, lovelies, you know it makes sense. If you can somehow explain the seeming correlation between you--... Wait no. That's wrong. If Rosey's action didn't go through, then Rosey can't have killed Katie. So, until someone else claims that their action didn't go through, Rosey can't have done it. Therefore, in all logic, Rosey has to be innocent until otherwise said so. Then, if Rosey's action didn't go through and Katie didn't kill someone, Katie must have tried to kill me because I healed myself. SO! TLDR: If Rosey's action didn't go through and she is innocent, then I blocked Katie. So if anyone believes Rosey on her action failing, they have to believe I blocked Katie's kill. UNVOTE Now, if the roleblock claims are both true, then Skelda CAN still be mafia but not third. Because in the first night it could have been Lizzy making the kill and not Skelda. Skelda was RBed but the kill still went through. In that case claiming the RB is fine, because what are the odds if anyone deduces this. Ye know what Rosey, VOTE SKELDA I am curious. |
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Aug 12, 2018 4:23:30 GMT -5
Vote: SkeldaCome on, lovelies, you know it makes sense. I don't know Rosey, there's too many people scummier in my opinion at this point. I don't want to vote him yet Who? Not Legend, surely. It’s just a bit too ballsy to fakeclaim town doctor on day one for me to seriously think he’s scum. |
|
|
|
Post by HungryPony27 on Aug 12, 2018 4:25:05 GMT -5
Except that's not how you've mentioned it the last few posts. If that's what this is all about then you should have said that straight away and I would have let it rest. Rather than saying that you seemed to bash the way I play doctor. But is the fact that Katie's kill didn't go through enough towncred to leave me be for at least the day? It should be. And no, in some cases the day 1 claim is very legitimate in my eyes. I made the conscious decision between death and playing doctor openly. It would have been so MUCH WORSE if I was dead right now because I genuinely believe that without my claim I would have been whacked day 1. I was at 3 votes at 1 point and the day 1 whack ended up winning with 3 votes. Besides, Look at the sheer amount of mafia carnage that's going on. We have only lost the one townie so far. Someone is doing something very right, now aren't day? Why else would I be stating those reasons if I wouldn't think you are scum? You really think I'd go after you if I didn't think you were scum? What would be the use of that? Also you wouldn't have been whacked if you had simply said I have a very powerful role that I don't wish to reveal yet. Or just wait and see because it's never the first one on the block who gets whacked in these big games. I also only remember Skelda voting you. Anyway, there's many townier ways you could've handled it. Yes, but I opted to go for open doctor. Why? because it gives information to town. I knew I had to make some sort of claim and figured that rather than being secretive, I'd share. No harm has been done by it, except that everyone thinks it's scummy to be honest. |
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Aug 12, 2018 4:25:29 GMT -5
Yeah! You and me, Legend, let’s paint the town red.
|
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Aug 12, 2018 4:26:07 GMT -5
|
|
