|
Post by Kat on Oct 6, 2017 9:28:15 GMT -5
The aliens have some of the best PR roles though.
|
|
|
Post by Kat on Oct 6, 2017 9:28:47 GMT -5
Jitter. Helder. Eaten whisky bottles. Which of these best describes the human foot? Eaten whisky bottles. Hands down. Or.. Foot down.
|
|
|
Post by choco on Oct 6, 2017 9:28:49 GMT -5
:cookies:
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Oct 6, 2017 9:36:34 GMT -5
Just look at Em's UPick game. Almost all scum was forced to pick scum. Only one person took mafia over town lol I know it's no guarantee but it's a chance. I don't really wanna go by discards anyway though. And now Goodnight! Greatest idea is randomized from a list. It's always like that, for better or worse. You've hosted this setup before. We've had times when there has only been one scum in play. UPicks are different. Sometimes one needs to gear, but even that is not common. I've never hosted Greatest idea and only played it once. However I hosted Greater Idea before and played it a few times. I know how it works and that you put the whole list of roles in the randomizer, pick the first two to send as choices to the player, remove them from the list to make sure there are no duplicates and repeat the process until everyone got their choices. I know balance isn't guaranteed, only that at least 50% of the players need to be town and at least 1 player has to be scum. However, it is still possible that someone rolled two scum roles. (And for scum I'm also counting Third Party) I never said it was a given that someone were forced to pick scum but there is a chance. I feel like people were misunderstanding me there. Or are you saying everyone who discarded a scum role is automatically town? Probably not. Just for fun I went back to older greater idea games to see how often it happens. I hosted two rounds. First round Swift was offered Mafia/Alien, second round Lala got Mafia/Third. Emily also hosted two rounds. First time Alleen got Mafia/Alien , Rosey was offered Werewolf/Werewolf and Lo got Third/Third. In the second round Lo got Third/Mafia and Tip got Alien/Werewolf. Then I checked Katie's game and in there Emily was offered Third/Werewolf. After that I got bored, so yeah. As you can see it happened in all these games. Of course that doesn't mean it has to happen in this game too but it could. That's all I'm going to say about that topic anymore. I still don't see why this thinking makes me scum though. Oh and yeah, Em messed up in her UPick because she handed out too many town roles and then realized she has to have some mafia too lol I agree that my comparison wasn't the best. So I'll give you that, Rosey xD
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Oct 6, 2017 9:39:27 GMT -5
How she is, at least it seems, trying to get people to be suspicious of others because of what they discarded. It is like she wants somebody whacked. I don't know if it is enough for a vote yet but maybe in the future if she acts more suspicious Well yeah, I want somebody to be whacked because that's our chance to get rid of the bad guys but not just ANYbody. Also, I've said before that I don't want to whack someone just based off their discards. Of course we still have to see who is acting suspicious and whatnot.
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Oct 6, 2017 9:43:14 GMT -5
I think Rosey is town. She's her usual self again. I don't trust Caro at all. I'm suspicious of Kitty. She feels scummy. Keyen and Floppy seem townish Katie seems to want to try and beat me at being a stump xD That's what stood out to me so far. You sure you don't just want revenge for last game? xD
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Oct 6, 2017 9:44:27 GMT -5
It's not really wise to waste an opportunity to whack though. I did it when I came here first. But if Skelda thaught me 1 thing, it's to never waste a whack. Good Point....I guess I'll Unvote No whack although I have no idea who to vote. Rose was quickly convinced lol
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Oct 6, 2017 9:46:05 GMT -5
There's quite a few more Town roles than scum roles in total, so Scum/Scum is the least likely combination.
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Oct 6, 2017 9:46:57 GMT -5
Never vote Rosey day 1. If she turns out to be scum she'll soon be obvious. Also Rosey is always offtopic. How else do you get a game to run day 1. It's annoying I find myself always defending Rosey, but man, for now she's really townish and she knows how to keep a game active. So I really don't want to lose her. That's a dumb rule though. If you find someone suspicious, go vote for them, no matter on what day it is. I'd make an exception if someone died early in the last game too or hasn't played for a while or is new...
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Oct 6, 2017 9:49:40 GMT -5
I honestly think Rosey is town at the moment. I feel kind of weird about Caro, but I'm not sure What made you change your mind? Earlier you said you have no opinion on me and then later you find me suspicous. Even though I wasn't around, so you still had the same posts to go on about lol Is it because everyone keeps talking about me?
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Oct 6, 2017 9:50:16 GMT -5
So please take of your votes from Rosey...
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Oct 6, 2017 9:51:01 GMT -5
Fine. UNvote Rosey
Vote: CaroCuz gravedigger is a cool role. Why did you throw that away? Caro Umm no. Gravedigger is the opposite of a cool role xD It doesn't help town in any way.
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Oct 6, 2017 9:51:27 GMT -5
You have to admit, Caro, you're not at your most townish right now.
What is your opinion on FloppyFish?
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Oct 6, 2017 9:52:45 GMT -5
I don't believe it has resurrecting powers. Oh yeah, you're right. I just re-read the set up and it doesn't have the resurrecting powers in this set up. Gah, I don't even know who to vote for now. I hate first days. My main gut feelings tell me it's either Rosey, Floppy, maybe Keyen. I think Caro's reasoning about the discarded choices makes sense. I feel like I'm the only other person who agrees with this? And now that you mentioned gravedigger isn't that exciting, then maybe Caro just picked a better role. It's possible she is scum or third but I am nor worried about her so much now. Rosey is being too friendly with the new people. I think she's trying to be all buddy buddy so these new people wouldn't suspect her later on. LOL. Floppy is against the discards thing and is going against it and she discarded a mafia goon role. I think she might be one of the people who got two scum options. Keyen voted for Broncos and then now he's changed it to Caro just cuz I voted for Caro and Caro is leading the votes now. I'mma vote for Floppy. She did this the other she was scum before and tried to act all town and innocent. I'm not gonna buy this. Sorry. If she ever dies and flips scum that will make you look a bit sus. but it is your thoughts at the beginning of the game so idk Vote: FloppyDeKay is pretty vote happy today lol First Rosey, then me, then Floppy. Let's see if she changes her vote again xD
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Oct 6, 2017 9:55:19 GMT -5
I find it funny how Dekay thinks Keyen followed him, while I have the funny feeling Dekay followed me. Trying to get a wagon going or something. So I suspect both Caro and Dekay at the moment, but not as the same alignment. I can assure you we are no werewolf buddies again. She could be bad though. I'm not sure yet.
|
|