|
Post by ApplelovePear on Oct 7, 2017 13:39:45 GMT -5
See, we even discussed our reply on our scum chat xD This doesn't make me feel any better, Em said not long ago that she's joked around being buddies with her actual scum buddy before.... Well, I haven't I only said I'm leaning town so far on Em, it seems like everyone keeps making too much of my small bits of trust. Yesterday people were like 'you trust Floppy!' while I only gave her benefit of doubt then. And now I'm saying I have a gut feeling, that I won't entirely trust, therefore I'm leaning town on Em, her behaviour is really neutral so far to me, and people say 'you think Em is town!'
|
|
|
Post by rosey1579 on Oct 7, 2017 13:39:46 GMT -5
Positively invested for town. I said that because she is either mafia or town. If she were mafia dayvig i think she would have waited and kept her power for later use for a quicker win. Just the way she went about doing that seemed townish. It would have been a very good time to use her power if she were scum. For one, Caro seemed scum to most, so even if she were wrong, it wouldn't make her look as bad. Plus, she probably thought Caro was bad anyway, even if she was scum. And, it is a free kill for her that would just make her look more town in the long run. Actually, Caro was generally townread at the time due to Skelda the previous day.
|
|
|
Post by Weemzy Queen on Oct 7, 2017 13:39:50 GMT -5
Positively invested for town. I said that because she is either mafia or town. If she were mafia dayvig i think she would have waited and kept her power for later use for a quicker win. Just the way she went about doing that seemed townish. It would have been a very good time to use her power if she were scum. For one, Caro seemed scum to most, so even if she were wrong, it wouldn't make her look as bad. Plus, she probably thought Caro was bad anyway, even if she was scum. And, it is a free kill for her that would just make her look more town in the long run. Well that is right enough. As town i feel like you would want to use that power quicker because as town you doubt yourself and as town you dont mind dying as much. As scum youre defiant and dont want to die so with that attitude (I do anyway) tend to hold onto powers expecting to keep living and to then use them for a pro scum advantage point when numbers dwindle. You know, strategy and all. As town youre not in that "strategic" mindset But i mean i dunno what goes on in sjaps mind so who knows. Thats just what i think. I think she is town. If she isn't well Oops
|
|
|
Post by notfloppyfish on Oct 7, 2017 13:41:47 GMT -5
It would have been a very good time to use her power if she were scum. For one, Caro seemed scum to most, so even if she were wrong, it wouldn't make her look as bad. Plus, she probably thought Caro was bad anyway, even if she was scum. And, it is a free kill for her that would just make her look more town in the long run. Actually, Caro was generally townread at the time due to Skelda the previous day. She had like, 2 or 3 votes. Lots agreed she was sus.
|
|
|
Post by Weemzy Queen on Oct 7, 2017 13:42:49 GMT -5
Or im town with a gut feeling. I know you really dont like "random guesses" and "gut feelings" So it is okay I forgive you. XD Maybe you should have said "gut feeling" instead of "scum". Gut feelings are random and often incorrect. I have gut feelings on people too but I don't go around acting like I have evidence for them saying they are scum when I really just have a gut feeling. I bet you are just trying to get a townie whacked and are looking for reasons to get Rosey whacked. Rosey has acted town and has been very helpful to town. It would make sense for you to target her. I only said i THINK rosey might be scum Usually when i say "i think" it meams it is a gut feeling. I would usually provide evidence or expand on my point if i do have a legit reason I just cant always be bothered to specify all the time that It is actually a gut feeling so i apologise if i sound as if im pushing on someone and sounding like i am hard on accusing them. I dont mean to sound like that
|
|
|
Post by notfloppyfish on Oct 7, 2017 13:43:02 GMT -5
It would have been a very good time to use her power if she were scum. For one, Caro seemed scum to most, so even if she were wrong, it wouldn't make her look as bad. Plus, she probably thought Caro was bad anyway, even if she was scum. And, it is a free kill for her that would just make her look more town in the long run. Well that is right enough. As town i feel like you would want to use that power quicker because as town you doubt yourself and as town you dont mind dying as much. As scum youre defiant and dont want to die so with that attitude (I do anyway) tend to hold onto powers expecting to keep living and to then use them for a pro scum advantage point when numbers dwindle. You know, strategy and all. As town youre not in that "strategic" mindset But i mean i dunno what goes on in sjaps mind so who knows. Thats just what i think. I think she is town. If she isn't well Oops And who says when there are at least 2 other scummy / mafia parties that scum wouldn't doubt themselves? I don't know what the scums / third are feeling but if they are really trying to find the other baddies they probably doubt themselves too.
|
|
|
Post by ApplelovePear on Oct 7, 2017 13:43:15 GMT -5
It would have been a very good time to use her power if she were scum. For one, Caro seemed scum to most, so even if she were wrong, it wouldn't make her look as bad. Plus, she probably thought Caro was bad anyway, even if she was scum. And, it is a free kill for her that would just make her look more town in the long run. Actually, Caro was generally townread at the time due to Skelda the previous day. If there was a big chance of whacking her I wouldn't have wasted my kill... I just saw nobody having any attention left for Caro and I couldn't take the gamble.
|
|
|
Post by ApplelovePear on Oct 7, 2017 13:43:33 GMT -5
Actually, Caro was generally townread at the time due to Skelda the previous day. She had like, 2 or 3 votes. Lots agreed she was sus. That was yesterday!
|
|
|
Post by notfloppyfish on Oct 7, 2017 13:44:44 GMT -5
She had like, 2 or 3 votes. Lots agreed she was sus. That was yesterday! I think people were still sus of her. They may have not been voting her but they were before and many were still sus.
|
|
|
Post by kitty on Oct 7, 2017 13:45:17 GMT -5
This is what makes think skelda diverted the Caro votes to someone else thinking he could get everyone believing she might be town, the attention did go off her like sjappie said.
|
|
|
Post by notfloppyfish on Oct 7, 2017 13:45:39 GMT -5
Maybe you should have said "gut feeling" instead of "scum". Gut feelings are random and often incorrect. I have gut feelings on people too but I don't go around acting like I have evidence for them saying they are scum when I really just have a gut feeling. I bet you are just trying to get a townie whacked and are looking for reasons to get Rosey whacked. Rosey has acted town and has been very helpful to town. It would make sense for you to target her. I only said i THINK rosey might be scum Usually when i say "i think" it meams it is a gut feeling. I would usually provide evidence or expand on my point if i do have a legit reason I just cant always be bothered to specify all the time that It is actually a gut feeling so i apologise if i sound as if im pushing on someone and sounding like i am hard on accusing them. I dont mean to sound like that Maybe you should make that clear then. Not everybody knows what "I think" means for every single person
|
|
|
Post by Weemzy Queen on Oct 7, 2017 13:46:18 GMT -5
Well that is right enough. As town i feel like you would want to use that power quicker because as town you doubt yourself and as town you dont mind dying as much. As scum youre defiant and dont want to die so with that attitude (I do anyway) tend to hold onto powers expecting to keep living and to then use them for a pro scum advantage point when numbers dwindle. You know, strategy and all. As town youre not in that "strategic" mindset But i mean i dunno what goes on in sjaps mind so who knows. Thats just what i think. I think she is town. If she isn't well Oops And who says when there are at least 2 other scummy / mafia parties that scum wouldn't doubt themselves? I don't know what the scums / third are feeling but if they are really trying to find the other baddies they probably doubt themselves too. Im just tryig to think about the possibilities and going by what I have felt in previous games. I dunno what other people think when they are scum in different situations. I havent been scum all that often in all the games I've played and all the times i have been scum there hasnt really been more than 1 scum faction for most of those Im just throwing in my 2 pence, that's all.
|
|
|
Post by Skelda on Oct 7, 2017 13:46:50 GMT -5
I'm getting a weird vibe from skelda, the more he says the more different he seems to me than other games. I don't think I trust him so much anymore, when I read what he says I just feel like he's not being as confident as usual. I don't know Have you even seen me accused before? I do not like being suspected. I'm pretty sure I've been universally townread every game that I've been in with you.
|
|
|
Post by notfloppyfish on Oct 7, 2017 13:47:16 GMT -5
This is what makes think skelda diverted the Caro votes to someone else thinking he could get everyone believing she might be town, the attention did go off her like sjappie said. Or maybe Skelda and sjappie are both aliens or mafia and wanted to get Skelda to look town, and they thought Caro was sure town so they killed her to make Skelda look town, but then Caro flipped scum. idk just thought of that. probably isn't the case tho
|
|
|
Post by kitty on Oct 7, 2017 13:47:58 GMT -5
This doesn't make me feel any better, Em said not long ago that she's joked around being buddies with her actual scum buddy before.... Well, I haven't I only said I'm leaning town so far on Em, it seems like everyone keeps making too much of my small bits of trust. Yesterday people were like 'you trust Floppy!' while I only gave her benefit of doubt then. And now I'm saying I have a gut feeling, that I won't entirely trust, therefore I'm leaning town on Em, her behaviour is really neutral so far to me, and people say 'you think Em is town!' Ny question was more in a joke kinda way but trying to sus things out at the same time, it's just how you said that and then Em came not long after saying you're town it just felt scummy to me, more her than you though. I'm more bothered about skelda atm.
|
|