|
|
Post by Iceman on Sept 11, 2017 5:00:13 GMT -5
Well, I don't know much about power roles. Is there some sort of role that allows a person to know the alignments of two people in one night? It could like, maybe Dahl targeted me and then Silent targeted Dahl and so maybe Silent gets info on both me and Dahl. It's possible that Dahl targeted me last night then since she suspected me. What about that role that Skelda discarded I think. The penguins. They can send a message to a person but the message isn't chosen / written by them. The message can include one name which is innocent or 3 names, one of which is mafia. What if she got a 3 name one and one of the players are already dead? Then the last 2 could be you and Dahl, so one of you must be bad according to the message. I don't know if this is the case but that's the only role I know of which can work like that That's possible. I wish Silent could clarify for us, though. |
|
|
|
Post by Zinnia on Sept 11, 2017 5:00:32 GMT -5
Unless it happened night 1, neither Dahl or Silent could have targeted DeKay.
|
|
|
|
Post by Nadine on Sept 11, 2017 5:02:41 GMT -5
That would make sense if I am remembering the role right. When the penguins target each other all night actions are stopped or something. And if Skelda got a penguin-like role, who is to say Emily didn't include two. I just checked his, his is a one shot though so that then doesn't make sense to have a partner.
But ehhh probably wrong
|
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Sept 11, 2017 5:05:15 GMT -5
Soo rosey received a message that Zinnia left the house and she confirmed that she did.
Keyen received a message that Sub didn't leave the house and I think she confirmed that too, right?
So far it seems like the messages are true then, unless Zinnia or Sub were lying.
It also seems like the role who is sending out the messages is a tracker that can send their results to one other player.
This seems more like a town role to me, what do you think?
I also wonder if the tracker receives the result themselves too or if they have to send them via a message to someone else. This way they could be messed up when being sent to a mafia player.
|
|
|
|
Post by Nadine on Sept 11, 2017 5:08:53 GMT -5
Soo rosey received a message that Zinnia left the house and she confirmed that she did. Keyen received a message that Sub didn't leave the house and I think she confirmed that too, right? So far it seems like the messages are true then, unless Zinnia or Sub were lying. It also seems like the role who is sending out the messages is a tracker that can send their results to one other player. This seems more like a town role to me, what do you think? I also wonder if the tracker receives the result themselves too or if they have to send them via a message to someone else. This way they could be messed up when being sent to a mafia player. I really can't see it as a mafia role, it wouldn't make sense because it wouldn't be very useful to them since they have to send the message away. If it is a mafia role they could choose to send it to their buddies (if it works like that) but then we would probably not have people telling us about the messages they received. |
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Sept 11, 2017 5:09:21 GMT -5
Unless it happened night 1, neither Dahl or Silent could have targeted DeKay. Because you targetted DeKay Night 2? |
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Sept 11, 2017 5:11:43 GMT -5
If Dahl flips town, then I'm going with Dekay being town. If Dahl flips mafia, then I'll go with Dekay being mafia. Simple as that. I don't understand why Silent thinks both would have the same alignment though. |
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Sept 11, 2017 5:13:11 GMT -5
Stay safe, Katie and Jake and anybody else in hurricane Irma... Mafia, please kill somebody. There's too many people here. XD So far, from what I've read, it seems like Dahl may be the most suspicious... I'd like to think Dekay is town, but... I don't know. That may be biased of me. If Dahl flips town, then I'm going with Dekay being town. If Dahl flips mafia, then I'll go with Dekay being mafia. Simple as that. I distrust Dahl, Caro and Keyen right now. Dahl because I don't know how they play. I don't remember why Caro, but I know she's one of the ones I distrust. Keyen seems fishy because they keep asking for everybody's opinion on people, and I'm thinking that may be a tactic to figure out who to night kill and frame somebody else for... I trust Dekay and Lala. But that may be biased... Everybody else, I'm not sure about... So, for now, Vote: Dahl Oh this quote earlier was weird. Quick quote made it look like I've said it lol |
|
|
|
Post by DeKay on Sept 11, 2017 5:13:51 GMT -5
Well, I don't know much about power roles. Is there some sort of role that allows a person to know the alignments of two people in one night? It could like, maybe Dahl targeted me and then Silent targeted Dahl and so maybe Silent gets info on both me and Dahl. It's possible that Dahl targeted me last night then since she suspected me. What about that role that Skelda discarded I think. The penguins. They can send a message to a person but the message isn't chosen / written by them. The message can include one name which is innocent or 3 names, one of which is mafia. What if she got a 3 name one and one of the players are already dead? Then the last 2 could be you and Dahl, so one of you must be bad according to the message. I don't know if this is the case but that's the only role I know of which can work like that That's possible. I was thinking it could also be some sort of role where the PR targets someone and then the host will reply back with another player who has the same alignment as the targeted player. Don't know if such role exists tho. I'm just using my imagination. XD |
|
|
|
Post by Your Favourite Vulpine on Sept 11, 2017 5:14:22 GMT -5
Me list. To throw my thoughts out. Feel free to use the information provided here and refine it. See what happens with it. 1. Keyen (Nicki Minaj) - Very vocal, in a way that I have no idea how to pinpoint him anymore. Could be town, could be maf, could be third... He did receive a message D1. 2. Submarine - Has been very quiet, might be a nuisance in late-game if their behaviour does not change. 3. Silent - Who again?  4. Tribbo - Not very memorable at the moment. I've seen you posting, but haven't really read into it. 5. Kitty - Quite against Caro, and abit against DeKay. Hmm. It'd depend on Caro's flip whether or not to trust her. 6. Jake - Hard to read because of atrocious writing style. I do remember him waving away the possibility of an arsonist among us. Been awhile since he played, or our guy? 7. Nadine - As of now I find her reliable, also . 8. Bella - Noticed, but overlooked for now. :/ Does have a PR. 9. Dahl - The way she handled Rosey's questioning made me more sus of her. 10. Caro - Hot 'n Cold, sometimes circumstances and actions make her look townish, sometimes they don't. As of now she's on the lower half on my town-list though. It's said that she's connected to DeKay though. One of the most active players though. 11. Ice - Also someone I should try and pay more attention to. Did mention Zinnia being inactive, while I'd beg to differ. Hmm. 12. Nani: Thunderbird- Doublevoter (Town) whackED DAY 113. Broncos - If s/he indeed wants to quit then I suggest Choco should take over. 14. Alleen: Qilin- 2-shot Rolecop (Scum) FIREBOMBED DAY 115. Rosey - I'm getting town vibes from you. Received a message, just like Keyen did N1. Rosey's message was true. There's a message role among us and probably town. 16. Vul (Vultimate Werewolf) - Too lurking, should participate more and get a better grasp on the game or else eventually a danger late-game because no idea what the f uc k is going on. 17. Skelda - Has lead the bandwagons against the D1 deaths. One town, one maf. Could swing boths sides still. 18. Hermy (BorkBork): Valkyrie, Mason Mimic (Third) to Third whackED DAY 219. Katie - I'm letting my worries of her getting trouble from Irma get in the way of her reads. I should focus on tha 20. Lala - I still think 3rd party, but benevolent to town. 21. DeKay - Crumbs, he says? Should be rereaded some more. Might either be a valuable town asset or a lying maf-kees (sorry for the lame pun  ). Has a PR nonetheless. 22. Zinnia (Catnip) - Like Ice, I've noticed her, but should pay more attention to her too. Does claim to have a PR and targeted DeKay last night. |
|
|
|
Post by DeKay on Sept 11, 2017 5:14:28 GMT -5
Unless it happened night 1, neither Dahl or Silent could have targeted DeKay. How are you so sure? |
|
|
|
Post by Caro on Sept 11, 2017 5:14:57 GMT -5
Maybe Silent has a role that compares people's alignment? Like she has to send in two names and then she will know if they are the same alignment or not and she sent in DeKay and Dahl and it says they are the same alignment? Idk if that role exists though.
|
|
|
|
Post by Zinnia on Sept 11, 2017 5:15:02 GMT -5
Unless it happened night 1, neither Dahl or Silent could have targeted DeKay. Because you targeted DeKay Night 2? Yeah, I should get to know if anyone targeted DeKay. However, there are at least 2 people in the game I won't be notified about. There is a chance there are more, but not such a great one that it is Silent and Dahl. |
|
|
|
Post by Nadine on Sept 11, 2017 5:15:19 GMT -5
If Dahl flips town, then I'm going with Dekay being town. If Dahl flips mafia, then I'll go with Dekay being mafia. Simple as that. I don't understand why Silent thinks both would have the same alignment though. Oooh, I see. That is weird and I can't think of a reason for that. She must see some sort of link between them. Anyway, Vote: DahlI don't particularly suspect you, but with all the opinions that have been given on you, this whack will be telling |
|
|
|
Post by Your Favourite Vulpine on Sept 11, 2017 5:15:33 GMT -5
Stay safe, Katie and Jake and anybody else in hurricane Irma... Mafia, please kill somebody. There's too many people here. XD So far, from what I've read, it seems like Dahl may be the most suspicious... I'd like to think Dekay is town, but... I don't know. That may be biased of me. If Dahl flips town, then I'm going with Dekay being town. If Dahl flips mafia, then I'll go with Dekay being mafia. Simple as that. I distrust Dahl, Caro and Keyen right now. Dahl because I don't know how they play. I don't remember why Caro, but I know she's one of the ones I distrust. Keyen seems fishy because they keep asking for everybody's opinion on people, and I'm thinking that may be a tactic to figure out who to night kill and frame somebody else for... I trust Dekay and Lala. But that may be biased... Everybody else, I'm not sure about... So, for now, Vote: Dahl Oh this quote earlier was weird. Quick quote made it look like I've said it lol OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH, Silent is Silentwolf!! Now I remember... |
|
