|
|
Post by Iceman on Sept 10, 2017 21:54:37 GMT -5
Okay, I'm done reading up on 20+ pages while I was asleep.
Here are my observations:
- Hermione allied herself with a third party player according to Emily, which implies that there is another third party player in this game. But given the lack of kills lately, maybe this one is a benign third party, or at least isn't actively killing people.
- We haven't had two night kills in a row, and Emily said there are at least 3 Mafia, so it can't be the case where we don't have any Mafia left in a game with 19 players. I'm beginning to suspect that the Mafia are inactive, or people who like to No Kill, even if it is a big game. According to the replies, Broncos is the living player with the least amount of replies on this thread, so she's fairly inactive. If she's town, she's not really helping us out. If she's scum, she's getting a free ride by making herself difficult to read. Rosey likes to No Kill too, but I don't think it might be her this time, and she doesn't have a good reason to do so right now.
Vote: Broncos
I want to hear more from her. And if we don't, town will be better off without inactive players.
|
|
|
|
Post by Lala on Sept 10, 2017 21:56:58 GMT -5
Katie, do you want me to vote for you because you are a serial killer? Is that what you want? Because I will. I have zero problemos doing that.
I really want to vote for Caro, though.
What does everyone think of Broncos? Am I on the wrong branch of the tree with her?
Dekay -- Dahl is a girl.
|
|
|
|
Post by Lala on Sept 10, 2017 21:57:30 GMT -5
Okay, I'm done reading up on 20+ pages while I was asleep. Here are my observations: - Hermione allied herself with a third party player according to Emily, which implies that there is another third party player in this game. But given the lack of kills lately, maybe this one is a benign third party, or at least isn't actively killing people. - We haven't had two night kills in a row, and Emily said there are at least 3 Mafia, so it can't be the case where we don't have any Mafia left in a game with 19 players. I'm beginning to suspect that the Mafia are inactive, or people who like to No Kill, even if it is a big game. According to the replies, Broncos is the living player with the least amount of replies on this thread, so she's fairly inactive. If she's town, she's not really helping us out. If she's scum, she's getting a free ride by making herself difficult to read. Rosey likes to No Kill too, but I don't think it might be her this time, and she doesn't have a good reason to do so right now. Vote: BroncosI want to hear more from her. And if we don't, town will be better off without inactive players. Yay. So I'm not alone on that branch of the tree. |
|
|
|
Post by Iceman on Sept 10, 2017 22:01:16 GMT -5
IDK. Since it's a role madness game, it's very much possible that both kills were blocked in the last two nights. But it seems likely that we also have inactive Mafia, given the number of players. And anyone who isn't speaking out can be harmful to town later on in the game.
In the last game I hosted, the night kills were blocked two nights in a row by two different people, but there had already been night kills at that point. Now, we haven't had a single one, which is pretty fishy.
|
|
|
|
Post by kitty on Sept 10, 2017 22:02:50 GMT -5
Oh yeah, DeKay said she trusts Caro to be town yesterday but now she votes Caro? That's very odd to me. Scumbuddies maybe, trying to throw your partner other under the bus now? That just makes DeKay even more scummy in my opinion. DeKay, that is a long post to quote so I'm just going to comment on the scum/scum connection. The alignments are randomized. There would be an equal chance of someone being offered scum/scum vs. scum/third vs. scum/town. With 5 discards, that means that less than 2 of the discards were offered scum/scum. We found 1. There's a definite chance that others were offered scum/scum, yes, but it's a pretty low chance. THe likelihood that a someone who discarded town (there were 15) was offered town/scum is also 1/3 ... or 5. Does that make sense? Math is not my strong suit, but statistics are that 5 people who discarded town were offered scum ... that's a lot. * * * * Keyen has been erratic, Jake. I understand your suspicion of him. I think he's likely third, but he could be a bad third. * * * * * DeKay, I also connect you and Caro. I find it interesting that you find her suspicious today because that throws one of my theories out the window, lol. I'm not buddies with Caro. I really would not want to go with Caro but I already explained my logic behind this earlier about the scum/scum possibility. And since Caro is having the most votes for now (I think), I would just vote for her to take a chance. I would also vote for Dahl if he has more votes later but I don't really know him that much to know his play style, so I don't know. You all can see who I feel the is the most scummy. With my gut feeling, I would say either Kitty, Skelda, Zinnia, Lala and maybe Rosey are scums. With logic, I'm going with Caro. Why are you so eager to get rid of me Kitty? I think you seem really scummy to me now. I'm gonna change my vote to you, just cuz I can.  Vote: Kitty
I didn't even vote you? Should I? You're honestly making me want to, you are acting seriously odd this game. You're being very defensive, just because I'm suspicious of you, you vote for me? Your votes don't even make sense... I can say that I am definitely not scum, I know it's easy to lie about it but I swear I'm not. If you look at when I was scum in Zinnia's game, I never once lied. I always said I wasn't mafia because I was actually werewolf but the question is can you confirm your role, no you can't because you don't want to because of your honesty. Well sorry but that just doesn't sit right with me, if you keep giving me reason I will go after you, after all I'm here to catch scum and you in my opinion are scummy but I'm not going to vote for you because you're going after me, I don't play like that. |
|
|
|
Post by Lala on Sept 10, 2017 22:02:58 GMT -5
This is the thing about Hermione, and one of the reasons I voted against her.
She claimed that in her role she was not allowed to vote until a certain requirement was met (which to me sounded quite fishy especially since she'd discarded an angel-type role). Since she was Mimic Masonizer person, does that mean that her third party mason buddy (who is third) has the requirement of not being able to vote either until something happens? Or did Hermione just make that whole shebang up?
A mimic copies -- what type of third party roles don't allow voting until a certain thing happens ... and would it be a town-positive thing?? Or a negative thing?
Does it even matter?
Has Dahl voted?
|
|
|
|
Post by Iceman on Sept 10, 2017 22:06:17 GMT -5
I don't think Dahl has voted.
|
|
nicki
Queen of Rap 
naughtynicki
super freaky girl
Posts: 6,986
|
Post by nicki on Sept 10, 2017 22:07:19 GMT -5
good morning nicki minaj is still the queen of rap
bookmarking page 146
|
|
|
|
Post by Zinnia on Sept 10, 2017 22:09:23 GMT -5
Okay, I'm done reading up on 20+ pages while I was asleep. Here are my observations: - Hermione allied herself with a third party player according to Emily, which implies that there is another third party player in this game. But given the lack of kills lately, maybe this one is a benign third party, or at least isn't actively killing people. - We haven't had two night kills in a row, and Emily said there are at least 3 Mafia, so it can't be the case where we don't have any Mafia left in a game with 19 players. I'm beginning to suspect that the Mafia are inactive, or people who like to No Kill, even if it is a big game. According to the replies, Broncos is the living player with the least amount of replies on this thread, so she's fairly inactive. If she's town, she's not really helping us out. If she's scum, she's getting a free ride by making herself difficult to read. Rosey likes to No Kill too, but I don't think it might be her this time, and she doesn't have a good reason to do so right now. Vote: BroncosI want to hear more from her. And if we don't, town will be better off without inactive players. If I am not mistaken, Broncos is gonna ask to be replaced since she can't keep up. |
|
|
|
Post by Lala on Sept 10, 2017 22:11:23 GMT -5
Okay, I'm done reading up on 20+ pages while I was asleep. Here are my observations: - Hermione allied herself with a third party player according to Emily, which implies that there is another third party player in this game. But given the lack of kills lately, maybe this one is a benign third party, or at least isn't actively killing people. - We haven't had two night kills in a row, and Emily said there are at least 3 Mafia, so it can't be the case where we don't have any Mafia left in a game with 19 players. I'm beginning to suspect that the Mafia are inactive, or people who like to No Kill, even if it is a big game. According to the replies, Broncos is the living player with the least amount of replies on this thread, so she's fairly inactive. If she's town, she's not really helping us out. If she's scum, she's getting a free ride by making herself difficult to read. Rosey likes to No Kill too, but I don't think it might be her this time, and she doesn't have a good reason to do so right now. Vote: BroncosI want to hear more from her. And if we don't, town will be better off without inactive players. If I am not mistaken, Broncos is gonna ask to be replaced since she can't keep up. Thank you ZInnia. Where did you hear that? |
|
|
|
Post by DeKay on Sept 10, 2017 22:13:07 GMT -5
Katie, do you want me to vote for you because you are a serial killer? Is that what you want? Because I will. I have zero problemos doing that. I really want to vote for Caro, though. What does everyone think of Broncos? Am I on the wrong branch of the tree with her? Dekay -- Dahl is a girl.Oh, oops sorry, Dahl. I don't know what to think of Broncos. Part of me also wants to just whack the inactive ones cuz that's why I usually do. But if we are going with the inactiveness logic, it could also mean that the other mafia is inactive (assuming there's only 2 mafia left). Do you guys think we should kill an inactive person now or just vote for the scummiest ones first? I'm open to anything since it's still early on in the game and we haven't lost a townie by nightkills. |
|
|
|
Post by DeKay on Sept 10, 2017 22:15:22 GMT -5
I'm not buddies with Caro. I really would not want to go with Caro but I already explained my logic behind this earlier about the scum/scum possibility. And since Caro is having the most votes for now (I think), I would just vote for her to take a chance. I would also vote for Dahl if he has more votes later but I don't really know him that much to know his play style, so I don't know. You all can see who I feel the is the most scummy. With my gut feeling, I would say either Kitty, Skelda, Zinnia, Lala and maybe Rosey are scums. With logic, I'm going with Caro. Why are you so eager to get rid of me Kitty? I think you seem really scummy to me now. I'm gonna change my vote to you, just cuz I can. Vote: Kitty
I didn't even vote you? Should I? You're honestly making me want to, you are acting seriously odd this game. You're being very defensive, just because I'm suspicious of you, you vote for me? Your votes don't even make sense... I can say that I am definitely not scum, I know it's easy to lie about it but I swear I'm not. If you look at when I was scum in Zinnia's game, I never once lied. I always said I wasn't mafia because I was actually werewolf but the question is can you confirm your role, no you can't because you don't want to because of your honesty. Well sorry but that just doesn't sit right with me, if you keep giving me reason I will go after you, after all I'm here to catch scum and you in my opinion are scummy but I'm not going to vote for you because you're going after me, I don't play like that. I know you haven't voted but what you said could possibly get other people to agree with you and then vote for me. If you are really town, why don't you investigate on me tonight then and find out for yourself (if your role allows it)? |
|
|
|
Post by Lala on Sept 10, 2017 22:16:09 GMT -5
I'd probably want to go with scummy right now. If Broncos is overwhelmed and wants to be replaced, Chocos might be able to step in -- I'd rather see it happen that way.
I'm going to unvote Broncos, and cast my vote in the morning after I wake up. It's late here, and I need to sleep.
Night all!
UNVOTE
|
|
|
|
Post by Zinnia on Sept 10, 2017 22:16:37 GMT -5
If I am not mistaken, Broncos is gonna ask to be replaced since she can't keep up. Thank you ZInnia. Where did you hear that? Discord. That's all that was said though "I'm probably going to replace out of Upick if I can, I can't keep up anymore" |
|
|
|
Post by Iceman on Sept 10, 2017 22:17:54 GMT -5
If Broncos is replaced, I'll take my vote off her.
I can go with either the scummiest people (although at this point I'm not even sure, with the lack of night kills) or the most inactive ones. Honestly, at this point it seems equally likely that the Mafia are inactive OR the Mafia's kills were prevented by PRs.
|
|
